Guides
Backup, archiving, evidence preservation: the differences in insolvency proceedings
Backup, archive and evidence preservation pursue different goals. This article explains the terms and shows which form is needed in which phase of insolvency proceedings.
“The data has been backed up” often means something quite different in proceedings from what those involved believe. Management means the nightly backup on the NAS, the IT service provider a copy of the servers, the administrator a repository they can still access in eight years' time, and the court-appointed expert a set of data whose unaltered state can be proven in court. These terms are used interchangeably in everyday life, but they pursue different goals and require different measures. This article explains the difference between backup, archiving and evidence preservation and shows which form is needed in which phase of the proceedings.
Backup: being able to restore
A backup in the narrower sense serves restoration: if a server fails, data is accidentally deleted or ransomware strikes, operations should continue with as little loss as possible.
Typical characteristics of a backup are:
- Currency over history. What matters is a state that is as current as possible. Older states are overwritten according to a rotation scheme.
- System focus. Entire servers, virtual machines or databases are backed up so that they can be restored quickly.
- Vendor formats. Backups are usually stored in a proprietary format of the backup software and can only be read with that software.
- Operational perspective. The backup serves the running business, not a third party who later has questions about the data.
In proceedings, this form is relevant above all in the continuation of business operations. As long as the debtor keeps working, the IT must remain available, and that requires a functioning backup.
Archiving: retaining and accessing
Archiving pursues a different goal. It is meant to keep records unaltered, complete and legible over a long period so that they can be found and evaluated again when needed. In the tax context, the focus is on the principles for the proper keeping and retention of books, records and documents in electronic form, GoBD for short.
Essential requirements for archiving are:
- Immutability. It must not be possible to alter archived data subsequently without this being detectable.
- Completeness. All records subject to retention must be captured, including the associated vouchers and metadata.
- Legibility and evaluability. Throughout the entire period, it must be possible to make the data legible and evaluate it by machine within a reasonable time.
- Order and retrievability. An archive is only useful if the records sought can be found in a targeted way.
- Access control. Who may access which parts must be defined and traceable.
In insolvency proceedings, archiving serves above all to fulfil the retention obligations that the administrator assumes under § 155 InsO (German Insolvency Code) and to make it possible to grant the tax authorities data access. It often extends beyond the end of the proceedings. More on this on the page on archiving with regard to retention obligations.
Evidence preservation: proving integrity
Evidence preservation, finally, is intended to prove that a set of data existed in a particular form at a particular time and has not been altered since. It is needed where data serves as the basis for contested claims: in avoidance actions, in claims against management, in criminal proceedings or in disputes with buyers.
Evidence preservation generally includes:
- Unaltered copy. Data carriers or data holdings are copied, wherever possible, in such a way that metadata, deleted areas and timestamps are also retained.
- Checksums. Cryptographic checksums are calculated over the preserved data, for example using the SHA-256 method. Any later change would lead to a different checksum.
- Chain of custody. It is documented without gaps who took over, transported, stored and processed the data, and when.
- Documentation of the approach. Source, time, tools used and results are recorded. A third party should be able to follow the approach.
- Working on copies. Only a working copy is analysed, never the preserved original.
How important clean documentation is for the administrator personally is examined in the article on the insolvency administrator's liability for data loss.
The three terms compared
The following overview sets out the differences side by side. The order in each case is: backup / archiving / evidence preservation.
- Main goal: restoring operations / retention and later access / proof of origin and unaltered state
- Time horizon: days to weeks / years, often beyond the proceedings / duration of possible litigation
- Handling of old states: overwritten by rotation / retained permanently / frozen state as at the cut-off date
- Format: mostly vendor-specific / as open and system-independent as possible / bit-for-bit copy with metadata
- Verifiability: test restore / legibility and evaluability / checksums and log
- Typical user: IT operations / administrator, tax authorities, auditors / administrator, court, experts
- Governing requirements: operational availability / GoBD, retention periods / documentation and traceability
In practice the three forms overlap. A well-executed preservation at the start of the proceedings can be the basis both for the later archive and for presenting evidence, provided it is documented accordingly from the outset.
Why the debtor's backup is often not enough
It is often assumed that the debtor's existing backups will take care of preservation. For several reasons, this is rarely the case.
- Rotation. Backups are overwritten according to a fixed scheme. Older states that would be important for reviewing avoidance claims often no longer exist, and ongoing operations overwrite further ones.
- Encryption. Modern backups are encrypted. If the key is known only to the former administrator or the service provider, the backup is worthless for the insolvency administration.
- Missing applications. A backup contains data, but not necessarily the specialist application that makes it legible. A merchandise management database without the associated software can hardly be evaluated.
- Gaps. Cloud services, local laptops, PST files or databases of individual departments are often missing from the central backup.
- Untested backups. Whether a backup can be restored at all has never been checked in many companies.
- No documentation. For evidential value, there is usually no proof of when the backup was created and whether it has remained unaltered since.
An existing backup is therefore no substitute for the administration's own preservation, but it can be a valuable supplement. Older backup states may contain data that has already been deleted in the current system. It is therefore worth recording existing backup media, protecting them from being overwritten and checking that they are legible.
In addition, the backup media themselves are often kept on the company's premises and are exposed to the same risks as the servers: sale, shutdown or access by unauthorised persons.
When you need what: typical phases of the proceedings
Which form is in the foreground depends on the stage of the proceedings.
Petition stage and preliminary administration
Here the aim is to protect the holdings from loss. What is needed is a complete preservation that at the same time meets the requirements of evidence preservation: documented, with checksums and frozen as at the cut-off date. The steps that count in the first days are described in the checklist for IT preservation after the insolvency petition.
Expert report and opening
For the court-ordered expert report, the preserved data is analysed, for example to establish the ground for insolvency or to determine the estate. Work is carried out on copies; the original remains untouched. More on this in the article on the insolvency expert report and IT data.
Continuation of business operations
If the business continues, the debtor needs a functioning operational backup. Alongside it, the cut-off-date preservation is retained as the unaltered baseline.
Closure of the business and realisation
Before servers and workstations are realised, all data subject to retention must have been transferred to an archive. The applications needed for legibility are preserved as well or virtualised.
Conclusion and aftermath
After the proceedings have been terminated, in many cases only archiving remains. It must be operated reliably and in a controlled manner for years, until the last periods have expired and the data can be erased.
Support from Beweisanker
Beweisanker combines the three forms in one continuous process. The preservation at the outset is carried out with documentation and checksums as insolvency data preservation. At the end of the proceedings, the holdings can be transferred into an archive package with a ten-year term. If you would like to clarify which form is needed in your proceedings right now, you can reach us via the contact page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between backup and archiving?
A backup serves the short-term restoration of systems and is regularly overwritten. Archiving keeps records over the long term, unaltered and evaluable, in order to fulfil retention obligations and enable later access.
Does a backup replace archiving in accordance with the GoBD?
As a rule, no. Backups are designed for restoration, are rotated and can often only be read with the original software. Retention over many years requires immutability, evaluability and order.
Why are checksums needed in evidence preservation?
A checksum is a digital fingerprint of the data holdings. If at a later point it matches the value recorded at the time of preservation, this proves that the data has not been altered since.
Can a single preservation fulfil all three purposes?
A carefully documented cut-off-date preservation can be the basis for evidence preservation and later archiving. For the continuation of business operations, an ongoing backup is needed in addition.
This article is for general information only and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.
Direct line
Urgent preservation?
Call us. We usually agree the scope and next steps during the first conversation.
- Response usually on the same working day
- Preservation on site or remotely
- Binding quotation in advance
Read more
More guides
Liquidating a GmbH: checklist for IT and data from the dissolution resolution to custody of the records
What managing directors and liquidators should do with accounts, cloud, accounting, servers, website, hardware and paper records in each phase of the liquidation, so that nothing is missing once the GmbH has been deleted.
Read article →Selling customer data in insolvency: value, permissibility, process
How insolvency administrators realise a customer database in an asset deal, which data may be transferred without consent and how the value of a customer base can be estimated reliably.
Read article →Continuation of business operations: keeping IT running in insolvency
How insolvency administrators keep IT stable during the continuation of business operations: critical systems, service providers and estate liabilities, key personnel, data preservation and an emergency plan.
Read article →