Guides

Domains in insolvency: securing, operating, realising

How insolvency administrators secure domains as assets of the estate, keep email and website running and realise domains together with the business or on their own.

A domain looks inconspicuous. It incurs low running costs, appears in no inventory list and is often managed by someone who left the company long ago. Yet the website, the email addresses, visibility in search engines and frequently also the sign-in to cloud services all depend on it. If a domain expires unnoticed in insolvency, customer communication is interrupted and a potential asset is lost. This article shows how to identify, secure, operate and realise domains in insolvency.

The domain as an asset of the estate

Legally, the domain itself is not property in the sense of a physical thing. Rather, the holder has contractual claims against the registry and, where applicable, against the registrar to keep the domain registered for it. According to the case law of the Federal Court of Justice, these claims are attachable as property rights. According to the prevailing view, it follows that they also form part of the insolvency estate and can be administered and realised by the insolvency administrator.

The value of a domain derives from various factors:

  • Recognition: Customers and suppliers know the address and use it for orders and communication.
  • Search engine ranking: A website that has grown over years with good visibility has an economic value of its own.
  • Short, generic name: Descriptive or very short domains can be in demand even without a business behind them.
  • Role in IT: The domain is often the basis for email, cloud accounts and certificates. Without it, other data is harder to preserve.

Whoever controls the domain controls email delivery. Secure access to domain management before, or at least in parallel with, the mailboxes.

Where domains are managed

In practice, the first hurdle is finding out where a domain is held at all. In companies that have grown over time, there is rarely a central overview. Typical places of management are:

  • Registrar: A provider that registers domains directly with the registry.
  • Reseller: A reseller that offers domains via a registrar in its own customer portal.
  • Hosting provider: Many web hosting and email packages include domains that are managed as part of the hosting contract.
  • IT service provider or agency: Often an IT system house or web agency registered the domain in its own customer account.
  • Private accounts of management: Particularly in smaller companies, the domain was sometimes created via the personal account of a shareholder or managing director.

Clues are provided by invoices in the accounts, entries in the Domain Name System, the data held by the registry and information from the debtor under § 97 InsO (German Insolvency Code). For .de domains, DENIC eG is the central registry. It provides information on the domain, although personal holder data is no longer freely available for data protection reasons. Information can be requested if there is a legitimate interest.

Particular care is needed where the domain is registered to a private individual or a service provider. Whether it nevertheless belongs to the estate depends on who is actually entitled under the arrangements made. This question should be clarified legally before a change of holder is initiated.

Taking over control: AuthInfo code and change of holder

For practical control, two processes must be distinguished. A change of provider moves technical management to a different registrar. A change of holder changes the registered domain holder.

  1. Secure access to the customer portal: Have the user name and password handed over, and change the password and the stored recovery email address.
  2. Request the AuthInfo code: A change of provider requires an authorisation code, called AuthInfo for .de domains. It is requested via the current provider.
  3. Check holder data: Are name, address and contact details correct? Is the debtor registered as the holder?
  4. Initiate the change of holder: Where necessary, the change is requested via the provider. This generally requires declarations from the previous holder or proof of the power of disposal, such as the insolvency administrator's certificate of appointment.
  5. Clarify payment status: Outstanding invoices should be checked so that the domain is not cancelled for non-payment.

The requirements for proof vary by provider and domain extension. Contacting the provider early saves follow-up queries.

Risks: expiry, deletion and takeover by third parties

The dangers to domains in insolvency usually arise quietly.

  • Expiry and deletion for non-payment: If the renewal fee remains unpaid, the provider cancels the domain. Depending on the extension and provider, there may then be a grace period during which restoration is possible; after that, the domain becomes available.
  • Domain grabbing: Released domains with visitor traffic are deliberately registered by third parties to resell them or use them for their own content.
  • Email outage: If the domain lapses, messages go nowhere. Customers, authorities and courts can no longer reach the company, without anyone knowing.
  • Takeover by third parties: Whoever takes over the domain can receive emails at the old address and reset passwords for linked accounts. This is a serious security risk, including for the data of the estate.

So in addition to the domain itself, also preserve the contents of the mailboxes. How to proceed is described in the article Email mailboxes in insolvency. For cloud mailboxes and linked services, preservation of Microsoft 365 and cloud services is a separate step.

Keeping email and website running

Even if business operations cease, it often makes sense to keep the domain and email running for a transitional period. This keeps customers and creditors able to get in touch, and incoming invoices, reminders or letters from authorities are not lost.

Proven measures are:

  • Out-of-office message: An automatic reply informs senders about the proceedings and gives a contact address of the administration.
  • Forwarding: Selected addresses, such as the invoice or info address, are forwarded to a mailbox of the administration.
  • Notice on the website: A simple page with information on the proceedings and contacts replaces the online presence.
  • Minimal operation: Hosting packages can be reduced to a low-cost tariff that keeps the domain and forwarding in place.

Hosting and email should only be terminated once the data has been preserved and it is certain that the domain is no longer needed. The orderly termination of such services is part of IT wind-down in insolvency proceedings.

Data protection when forwarding emails

Forwarding emails is not trivial in data protection terms. Personal addresses of former employees may contain private messages if private use was permitted or tolerated. Blanket forwarding of all addresses to the administration is therefore problematic.

Preferably forward functional addresses, and set up an out-of-office message with an alternative contact address for personal addresses. Record the decision and its reasons in writing.

Further points to note:

  • Forwarding should be limited in time and restricted to what is necessary.
  • Messages that are recognisably private should not be opened or analysed.
  • In opened proceedings, responsibility for processing personal data lies with the insolvency administrator.
  • A brief note in the case file makes later queries easier.

Valuation and realisation

There are essentially two routes to realisation. In a sale together with the business, the domain is transferred to the buyer along with trademarks, customer base and website. Here it is often a natural part of the purchase agreement and should be expressly named in it. In a separate realisation, the domain is sold on its own, for example via specialised domain marketplaces or auction platforms. The marketplaces' escrow procedures ensure that purchase price and domain are exchanged simultaneously.

Length, extension, industry relevance, visitor numbers and search engine visibility all feed into the valuation. Reliable values often only emerge by approaching the market.

It is important to check third-party trademark rights. If the domain contains someone else's trademark or company name, the sale may give rise to legal claims. Conversely, for a domain that matches the debtor's company name, it must be clarified whether company name and trademark rights are transferred as well. For .de domains, there may also be a dispute entry at DENIC that restricts transfers.

How Beweisanker supports you

Beweisanker helps to identify domains and associated services, secure access and fully capture email holdings before termination. Insolvency data preservation also covers mailboxes and website content, so that nothing is lost after realisation or shutdown. If you have questions about a specific case, please get in contact.

Frequently asked questions

Is a domain part of the insolvency estate?

According to the case law of the Federal Court of Justice, the holder's claims against the registry are attachable property rights. According to the prevailing view, they therefore fall into the insolvency estate, provided the debtor is the rightful holder.

What if the domain is registered privately to the managing director?

It must then be clarified to whom the domain actually belongs under the arrangements made. Until this is resolved, it should be protected against expiry and transfer. A legal review in the individual case is advisable.

How long should email remain reachable after business closure?

There is no fixed period. It makes sense to keep it running as long as relevant incoming messages from customers, creditors or authorities can still be expected and the data has not yet been fully preserved.

Can a domain be sold separately from the business?

Yes, domains can be realised individually, for example via domain marketplaces. Third-party trademark rights and possible dispute entries should be checked beforehand.

This article is for general information only and does not replace legal advice in the individual case.

Direct line

Urgent preservation?

Call us. We usually agree the scope and next steps during the first conversation.

  • Response usually on the same working day
  • Preservation on site or remotely
  • Binding quotation in advance

Read more

More guides

Liquidating a GmbH: checklist for IT and data from the dissolution resolution to custody of the records

What managing directors and liquidators should do with accounts, cloud, accounting, servers, website, hardware and paper records in each phase of the liquidation, so that nothing is missing once the GmbH has been deleted.

Read article →

Selling customer data in insolvency: value, permissibility, process

How insolvency administrators realise a customer database in an asset deal, which data may be transferred without consent and how the value of a customer base can be estimated reliably.

Read article →

Continuation of business operations: keeping IT running in insolvency

How insolvency administrators keep IT stable during the continuation of business operations: critical systems, service providers and estate liabilities, key personnel, data preservation and an emergency plan.

Read article →

Every day counts.

Talk to us as soon as proceedings are on the horizon. Together we establish which systems are affected and what needs to be preserved first.

Operating nationwide (Germany) · on site at short notice in Baden-Württemberg and German-speaking Switzerland