Guides

Retention obligations in insolvency proceedings: what applies to digital records?

Which retention periods apply to digital records in insolvency proceedings, when they begin and who retains the records after the proceedings end. With notes on costs, data protection and implementation.

Bookkeeping and retention obligations do not end with the opening of insolvency proceedings. In practice, they pass to the insolvency administration and often extend well beyond the end of the proceedings. For digital records, a particular question arises: how do accounting data, e-mails and vouchers remain readable and analysable for up to ten years when the original systems have long been switched off? This article provides an overview of the insolvency administrator's retention obligation and its practical implementation.

Legal basis: § 155 InsO

Under § 155(1) InsO (German Insolvency Code), the debtor's obligations under commercial and tax law regarding bookkeeping and accounting remain unaffected. With regard to the insolvency estate, the insolvency administrator must fulfil these obligations. According to general understanding, the bookkeeping obligations also include the obligation to retain the records.

In addition, under § 36(2) no. 1 InsO the business books form part of the insolvency estate. The administrator takes possession of them under § 148 InsO. From the opening of proceedings, responsibility for preserving the records, including digital ones, therefore lies in practice with the administration.

The retention periods under § 257 HGB and § 147 AO

Commercial law (§ 257 HGB, German Commercial Code) and tax law (§ 147 AO, German Fiscal Code) govern retention largely in parallel. Since 1 January 2025, amended periods for accounting vouchers have applied as a result of the Fourth Bureaucracy Relief Act. An overview:

  • 10 years: commercial books and records, inventories, opening balance sheets, annual financial statements and management reports, as well as the working instructions and organisational documents required to understand them.
  • 8 years: accounting vouchers, such as invoices, bank statements and receipts. Until the end of 2024, ten years applied here.
  • 6 years: commercial and business letters received and sent, as well as other tax-relevant records, unless a longer period applies.

Important for insolvency practice: commercial and business letters are not just paper post. E-mails can also be commercial letters if they prepare, conclude, perform or reverse a transaction. An e-mail archive is therefore regularly among the records subject to retention.

Whether the shortened period of eight years applies to a specific legacy holding depends on the transitional provisions. In case of doubt, the question should be clarified with your tax advisers before vouchers are destroyed.

When does the period begin?

Under § 257(5) HGB and § 147(4) AO, the retention period begins at the end of the calendar year in which the last entry was made in the book, the inventory was drawn up, the commercial letter was received or sent, or the accounting voucher was created. An invoice from June 2026 is therefore counted from 31 December 2026.

For tax purposes there is an additional special feature: under § 147(3) AO, the retention period does not expire insofar and for as long as the records are relevant for taxes for which the assessment period has not yet expired. This suspension of expiry can considerably extend retention in individual cases, for example in the case of ongoing tax audits or open tax assessments.

What does this mean for digital records?

Digital records must not only exist, but must remain readable throughout the entire period and, where relevant for tax purposes, machine-analysable. Under § 147(2) AO, records created with the aid of a data processing system must be available at any time during the retention period and capable of being made readable without delay and analysed by machine. The tax authorities also have a right of data access under § 147(6) AO. Further details are explained in the article Data access by the tax authorities after business closure.

For electronically generated accounting data, a printout or a PDF export generally does not fully meet these requirements. In practice, it has therefore proved effective to preserve the original system and keep it operable as a virtual machine. In this way, accounting and merchandise management remain usable in their familiar form without the old hardware having to be operated.

Who retains the records after the proceedings end?

The retention periods usually end only years after the proceedings have been closed or discontinued. Who keeps the records thereafter depends on the legal form and the circumstances:

  • In the case of a natural person or a company that continues to exist, the records can in principle be returned to the debtor, provided the debtor can ensure their retention.
  • In the case of a GmbH that is deleted after the proceedings have been concluded, § 74(2) GmbHG provides that the books and records are to be placed in the safekeeping of one of the shareholders or a third party for ten years. The person or body is determined in the articles of association, by shareholder resolution or by the court.
  • In many cases, custody in fact remains with the administrator or is organised by them, for example by engaging a service provider.

The precise responsibility must be clarified in the individual case. It is important to settle and document it early, so that the records can be found in a later tax audit or in liability litigation.

Costs of retention

Retention incurs costs for storage, operation and, where applicable, licences. During the proceedings, they are generally borne by the insolvency estate. For the period after the proceedings end, it is advisable to calculate the expected costs before the final account and to take them into account accordingly.

Costs can be reduced by archiving long-term only the holdings that are subject to retention and relevant to the proceedings, by not running the legacy system permanently on its own hardware, and by choosing open formats that remain readable without expensive licences. A binding quotation with a clear term provides planning certainty. Further information can be found on the page Archiving and retention obligations.

The tension with data protection

Retention obligations and data protection are in tension. According to the prevailing view, the insolvency administrator is the controller for the processing of the debtor's data. The obligations of the GDPR therefore apply to them:

  • Data minimisation and storage limitation (Art. 5 GDPR): Data may only be stored for as long as is necessary for the purpose.
  • Right to erasure (Art. 17 GDPR): The right to erasure does not apply insofar as a statutory retention obligation precludes it. After the period has expired, however, data must be erased.
  • Security of processing (Art. 32 GDPR): Archived data must be protected by appropriate technical and organisational measures, such as encryption, access restriction and logging.

In practice this means: retain what must be retained, but protected and with a clear erasure date. Personal data without a reason for retention, such as private files on workstation computers, should not be carried along indefinitely. The end point is a verifiable erasure with an erasure certificate.

Practical implementation

The following approach has proved effective for implementation in the law firm:

  1. Preserve everything. At the outset, preserve all systems, including e-mail and cloud, and document the backup with checksums.
  2. Classify. Assign holdings according to retention period: books and financial statements, accounting vouchers, commercial letters, other records.
  3. Maintain analysability. Keep tax-relevant systems operable, for example through virtualisation, instead of merely filing exports.
  4. Calculate periods. Determine the latest end of the period for each category and take possible suspensions of expiry into account.
  5. Arrange custody. Before the proceedings end, determine who keeps the records where and who is granted access.
  6. Erase. After the period has expired, erase verifiably and retain the erasure certificate.

How we support law firms in this is described on the page for insolvency administrators.

Frequently asked questions

Does § 155 InsO also apply to digital records?

Yes. § 155 InsO does not distinguish between paper and electronic records. Electronically kept books and vouchers are subject to the same obligations and, in addition, to the requirements for machine analysability under § 147(2) and (6) AO.

Are e-mails subject to retention?

E-mails are subject to retention insofar as they are commercial or business letters or otherwise contain tax-relevant information. The period is then generally six years. Separating relevant from irrelevant e-mails is laborious, which is why the entire mailbox is often preserved.

May the administrator destroy records after the proceedings end?

Not while retention periods are running. Custody must be arranged before the proceedings end, for example under § 74(2) GmbHG in the case of a deleted GmbH. Only after the period has expired, taking the suspension of expiry into account, can destruction be considered.

Who bears the costs of retention?

During the proceedings, the costs are generally borne by the insolvency estate. For the period thereafter, funding should be planned before the final account. The details depend on the proceedings.

Note: This article is for general information purposes and does not replace legal advice in the individual case. The applicable provisions in force and the circumstances of the specific proceedings are decisive.

Direct line

Urgent preservation?

Call us. We usually agree the scope and next steps during the first conversation.

  • Response usually on the same working day
  • Preservation on site or remotely
  • Binding quotation in advance

Read more

More guides

Liquidating a GmbH: checklist for IT and data from the dissolution resolution to custody of the records

What managing directors and liquidators should do with accounts, cloud, accounting, servers, website, hardware and paper records in each phase of the liquidation, so that nothing is missing once the GmbH has been deleted.

Read article →

Selling customer data in insolvency: value, permissibility, process

How insolvency administrators realise a customer database in an asset deal, which data may be transferred without consent and how the value of a customer base can be estimated reliably.

Read article →

Continuation of business operations: keeping IT running in insolvency

How insolvency administrators keep IT stable during the continuation of business operations: critical systems, service providers and estate liabilities, key personnel, data preservation and an emergency plan.

Read article →

Every day counts.

Talk to us as soon as proceedings are on the horizon. Together we establish which systems are affected and what needs to be preserved first.

Operating nationwide (Germany) · on site at short notice in Baden-Württemberg and German-speaking Switzerland