Guides
Tax data access (Z1, Z2, Z3) after business closure
How insolvency administrators ensure the tax authorities' data access under § 147(6) AO even after business closure. With an explanation of Z1, Z2 and Z3 and virtualisation as the solution.
When an insolvent company ceases operations, servers are switched off and software licences cancelled. The tax obligations, however, continue, and with them the tax authorities' right to access the electronic data. For insolvency administrators, the question therefore arises of how data access under § 147(6) AO (German Fiscal Code) can still be guaranteed years after business closure. This article explains the access types Z1, Z2 and Z3 and shows which technical solutions prove themselves in practice.
Starting point: tax obligations in insolvency
Under § 155 InsO (German Insolvency Code), the commercial and tax-law obligations regarding bookkeeping and financial reporting continue in insolvency proceedings. The insolvency administrator fulfils them in respect of the insolvency estate. This includes retaining the records under § 147 AO and, where they were kept electronically, keeping them machine-analysable.
Tax audits do take place in insolvency, for example for periods before the petition was filed, to examine refund claims or in connection with VAT. The tax authorities may wish to access the electronic data in doing so, regardless of whether the company is still trading.
What does § 147(6) AO provide?
§ 147(6) AO gives the tax authority the right, in the course of an external tax audit, to inspect the stored data and to use the data processing system for the audit if the records were created with the help of such a system. It may also require the data to be analysed by machine according to its specifications or transmitted to it in a machine-analysable format.
The details are set out in the principles for the proper keeping and retention of books, records and documents in electronic form and for data access, known as the GoBD. The GoBD are a circular from the Federal Ministry of Finance and bind the tax authorities. For taxpayers, they provide important guidance on how the authorities interpret the statutory requirements.
The three access types at a glance
Z1: direct data access
With direct data access, the tax auditor is given read-only access to the taxpayer's data processing system. The data is viewed, filtered and sorted in the original system, using the analysis functions the system itself offers. The prerequisite is therefore that the original system, such as the financial accounting software, is still running and operable.
Z2: indirect data access
With indirect data access, the taxpayer or a third party engaged by it analyses the data according to the tax authorities' specifications. The auditor does not operate the system personally but specifies which analyses are to be produced. Here too, a functioning system is needed that can produce the required analyses.
Z3: provision of data media
With the provision of data media, the data subject to recording and retention obligations is handed over in a machine-analysable format so that the tax authorities can analyse it with their own audit software. Many accounting programs, such as those from DATEV, offer export functions in standardised formats for this purpose. The export must contain the data in full and with the associated structural information.
The tax authorities can in principle choose which access type to use, and may also combine several. Anyone who only keeps an export may be unable to satisfy Z1 and Z2.
Why a PDF export is not enough
An obvious thought at business closure is to print journals, account sheets and balance sheets as PDFs and then switch the system off. For data access, this is generally not sufficient. A PDF is an image, not a machine-analysable database. It cannot be filtered, sorted or read into audit software. In addition, the links between posting, voucher and master data are lost.
Even a single data export is only as good as its completeness. If master data, subsidiary ledgers or change logs are missing, the audit may object to gaps. And if the tax authorities require Z1 or Z2, an export on its own is of no help.
System changes and shutdown
The GoBD contain rules for cases where a company changes its data processing system or moves data to another system. In principle, machine analysability must be preserved in these cases too. Under the GoBD, after the end of the fifth calendar year following the changeover, it may be sufficient to offer only the provision of data media. Until then, access in the forms Z1 and Z2 must in principle also be ensured.
For insolvency, this means: if the financial accounting system is switched off when operations cease, an operational system should remain available for a considerable part of the retention period. Whether the business closure is to be treated like a system change in the individual case should be agreed with the tax adviser.
Virtualisation as a practical solution
Continuing to run the original server for years is expensive and risky. Hardware ages, maintenance contracts end, premises are vacated. A proven solution is virtualisation: the original system is preserved as a complete image and then operated as a virtual machine, independent of the old hardware.
The advantages at a glance:
- Z1 and Z2 remain possible. The financial accounting runs in its familiar form. Read-only access for the audit can be set up, and analyses can be produced to specification.
- Z3 remains available at any time. Exports in the required formats can be generated from the running system as needed.
- Integrity can be proven. The preserved image is documented with checksums. The virtual environment can be operated in such a way that the original data remains unaltered.
- Predictable costs. The virtual machine only needs to run when required. Ongoing hardware and maintenance costs no longer apply.
- Further use. The same system also serves the administration, for example for debt collection or avoidance reviews.
Licensing questions, such as whether the software may be used in virtualised form, should be examined in the individual case. More on the technical implementation can be found on the page Virtualisation of legacy systems.
Typical mistakes at business closure
In practice, the following omissions in particular jeopardise later data access:
- Shutting down without a complete preservation. If the server is switched off and realised before a complete image exists, Z1 and Z2 can hardly be restored.
- Preserving only the database. Without the associated application, its version and configuration, a database often can no longer be meaningfully analysed.
- Forgetting licence and activation keys. Some programs will not start after a reinstallation without activation by the manufacturer. Licence documents should be preserved as well.
- Not documenting credentials. An operational system is of little use if, years later, nobody knows the administrator password any more.
- Overlooking outsourced data. If posting data is held by the tax adviser or in a cloud application, these holdings must also be preserved or their availability clarified contractually.
Tax audit after insolvency
If the tax authorities announce an external audit, it helps if the following points have already been prepared:
- An overview of the preserved systems with the time and scope of preservation.
- An operational, virtualised system for financial accounting and, where applicable, merchandise management.
- Read-only access set up and limited to the data relevant to the audit.
- The ability to produce analyses to specification.
- A complete export in a machine-analysable format.
- The procedural documentation or at least a description of the system landscape.
Access for third parties should be controlled and logged. Personal data not required for the audit should not be accessible. This is where the administrator's obligations as controller under the GDPR apply. Further information on periods can be found in the article Retention obligations in insolvency proceedings, and on researching the holdings on the page Data preparation and research.
Frequently asked questions
Must the insolvency administrator enable data access under § 147(6) AO?
Under § 155 InsO, the administrator fulfils the tax obligations in respect of the estate. According to the prevailing view, this also includes creating the conditions for data access, insofar as the records were kept electronically.
Is a DATEV export enough for the tax audit?
A complete export can cover the provision of data media (Z3). If the tax authorities require direct or indirect access, an operational system is also needed.
How long must the legacy system remain operational?
In principle, for the duration of the retention period. Under the GoBD, after a system change, the provision of data media may suffice from the end of the fifth calendar year after the changeover. Its application to the individual case should be checked from a tax perspective.
Can the auditor access a virtualised system directly?
Yes, controlled read-only access to the virtualised environment is technically possible, on site or via secure remote access. It is limited to the data relevant to the audit and logged.
Note: This article is for general information only and does not replace legal advice in the individual case. The applicable provisions and the circumstances of the specific proceedings are decisive.
Direct line
Urgent preservation?
Call us. We usually agree the scope and next steps during the first conversation.
- Response usually on the same working day
- Preservation on site or remotely
- Binding quotation in advance
Read more
More guides
Liquidating a GmbH: checklist for IT and data from the dissolution resolution to custody of the records
What managing directors and liquidators should do with accounts, cloud, accounting, servers, website, hardware and paper records in each phase of the liquidation, so that nothing is missing once the GmbH has been deleted.
Read article →Selling customer data in insolvency: value, permissibility, process
How insolvency administrators realise a customer database in an asset deal, which data may be transferred without consent and how the value of a customer base can be estimated reliably.
Read article →Continuation of business operations: keeping IT running in insolvency
How insolvency administrators keep IT stable during the continuation of business operations: critical systems, service providers and estate liabilities, key personnel, data preservation and an emergency plan.
Read article →