Guides
Personnel files and payroll data in insolvency
Why personnel files and payroll data in insolvency require particular protection, what they are needed for in the proceedings and how you organise retention, access and handover.
The insolvency benefit certificate is due to go to the Federal Employment Agency (Agentur für Arbeit), several employees are requesting references, and the social data needed for the dismissals is missing. Payroll used to be run by the tax adviser, who has blocked access because of unpaid fees, or by software whose licence has expired. Personnel files and payroll data in insolvency often only become an issue when they are urgently needed. This article shows why this data must be handled with particular care, what it is needed for in the proceedings and how you organise access, retention and handover.
Why employee data is particularly sensitive
Personnel files and payroll records contain far more than name and salary. They typically include:
- bank details, tax ID and social security number,
- information on religious affiliation via the church tax indicator,
- indications of a severe disability or equivalent status,
- periods of incapacity for work, phased return to work and maternity protection,
- wage garnishments and maintenance obligations,
- warnings, appraisals and target agreements.
Some of this falls within the special categories of personal data under Art. 9 GDPR, in particular health data and information on religious beliefs. Their processing is only permitted under strict conditions, for example insofar as it is necessary to fulfil obligations under employment and social security law. Upon appointment, the administrator assumes responsibility for this data. They must therefore ensure not only that the data remains available, but also that it is viewed only by those who need it for their task.
What personnel and payroll data is needed for in the proceedings
Hardly any other data set is needed so early and so often in the proceedings. Typical occasions are:
- Insolvency benefit (Insolvenzgeld): For the employees' application to the Federal Employment Agency, an insolvency benefit certificate is required that shows the unpaid remuneration for the insolvency benefit period. This requires the payslips for the last months before the insolvency event.
- Employment certificates: When employment relationships end, employment certificates (Arbeitsbescheinigungen) must be issued for the Federal Employment Agency.
- References: Departing employees are entitled to an employment reference. The basis is the personnel file, appraisals and job descriptions.
- Dismissals: For the social selection, length of service, age, maintenance obligations and severe disability are required; for the notice periods, the contract data.
- Reconciliation of interests and social plan: In the case of operational changes, staff lists and remuneration data are prepared for negotiations with the works council.
- Audit by the pension insurance: The German Pension Insurance (Deutsche Rentenversicherung) audits the proper payment of social security contributions. Audits can also take place after the opening of proceedings or the discontinuation of the business and require analysable remuneration records.
- Wage tax audit and examination of claims: The tax office and social security institutions also file claims whose examination relies on the payroll data.
Clarify early whether the payslips for the last months before the application are complete. If they are missing, insolvency benefit certificates are delayed and employees wait for their money.
Retention periods for payroll and personnel records
Several, partly overlapping periods apply to payroll and personnel records. An overview of the most important rules, which must be checked in the individual case:
- Payroll account under § 41 EStG (German Income Tax Act): The payroll account must be retained until the end of the sixth calendar year following the last recorded wage payment.
- Remuneration records under § 28f SGB IV (German Social Code, Book IV): Employers must keep remuneration records and contribution statements in an orderly manner until the end of the calendar year following the last audit by the pension insurance institution.
- Payroll vouchers: Insofar as payroll records serve as accounting vouchers, the eight-year period under tax and commercial law applies to them.
- Other personnel records: There is no uniform statutory period for employment contracts, references or warnings. Here, possible claims and limitation periods must be weighed against the data protection principle of storage limitation.
The periods continue to run regardless of the status of the proceedings. They may therefore extend beyond the closure of the proceedings. The general principles are explained in the article on retention obligations for digital records. Which period is decisive for a particular record should be checked in the individual case, especially as statutory periods have changed several times in recent years.
Where the data is actually held
Unlike financial accounting, payroll is often not done in-house. Before you can preserve it, you need to know where the data is processed.
Payroll at the tax adviser
Many small and medium-sized companies have their payroll run by their tax adviser, often with DATEV Lohn und Gehalt or LODAS. The master and transaction data is then held in the data centre or in the adviser's firm environment, not with the debtor. The administrator needs the firm's cooperation to obtain complete reports and exports. Guidance on access and handover is given in the article on DATEV data in insolvency.
In-house payroll software
If payroll is run in-house, the database is usually on a local server or with a cloud provider. In addition to the data itself, the application is needed in order to present payroll accounts, contribution statements and filings traceably later on. A pure database export is often not sufficient for this.
The electronic filings generated from the payroll software must also be preserved. These include social security notifications, contribution statements to the health insurance funds, wage tax returns and retrieved incapacity-for-work data. These processes are logged in the software and are often difficult to reconstruct without access to the application. Particularly in a later audit, reconciling payroll with the reported figures is a central audit step.
External payroll service providers
Specialised service providers sometimes take over the entire payroll. Here it must be clarified which data will be handed over at the end of the contract, in what format and by when. Many contracts provide only a limited period for retrieving data after termination.
Supplementary sources
Time recording systems, travel expense accounting, applicant management and the electronic personnel file contain further data that may be relevant for references, overtime claims or disputes. Physical personnel files on paper exist in parallel in many companies. They should be kept locked away and included in the inventory, even though the focus today is usually on digital data.
Access restriction and erasure concept
Within the administration, payroll and personnel data should be treated separately from the other preserved holdings. The following has proved effective:
- Separate preserved holding. Payroll and personnel data is preserved separately and stored encrypted.
- Authorisation concept. Only the persons who handle insolvency benefit, employment certificates or dismissals are given access. A data analysis for insolvency avoidance generally does not require health data.
- Logging. Access to particularly sensitive holdings is documented.
- Erasure concept. For each data category it is determined when it is no longer needed. Once the periods have expired, the data must be erased, including in backup copies.
- Do not forget data media. If servers or workstations of the HR department are remarketed, the data media must first be verifiably erased. More on this on the page on data erasure and hardware remarketing.
Handover in the event of a transfer of business
If the business is transferred in whole or in part, the employment relationships in principle pass to the purchaser under § 613a BGB (German Civil Code), even though special features must be observed in insolvency proceedings. Along with the employment relationships, the purchaser generally needs the associated personnel files and payroll master data.
From a data protection perspective, a distinction must be made:
- The data of the transferring employees is handed over to the purchaser insofar as they need it to continue the employment relationships.
- Data of employees who have objected or have left remains with the administration and may not be passed on wholesale.
- The administration may itself have to continue holding records subject to retention for the period before the transfer, for example for a later audit.
The precise arrangements for the handover should be legally reviewed in the individual case and recorded in writing. Technically, it is advisable to preserve a complete state before the handover so that the administration can continue to fulfil its own obligations.
Support from Beweisanker
Beweisanker preserves payroll and personnel data from in-house software, from tax advisers' environments and from service providers as a separate, access-restricted holding. Preservation is part of our insolvency data preservation. For the period after the proceedings, we take over archiving with regard to retention obligations on request. Your enquiry reaches us via the contact page.
Frequently asked questions
Who issues the insolvency benefit certificate in insolvency proceedings?
The certificate is generally issued by the insolvency administrator. For this they need the payslips for the insolvency benefit period, which should therefore be preserved early.
How long must payroll records be retained?
The payroll account until the end of the sixth calendar year after the last entry, remuneration records under § 28f SGB IV until the end of the calendar year after the last audit, payroll vouchers for eight years. The decisive period must be checked in the individual case.
May the tax adviser refuse to hand over the payroll data?
Whether and to what extent a right of retention exists depends on the type of records and the circumstances and must be legally reviewed. In practice, the handover of the required data can often be settled through early coordination with the firm.
What happens to personnel files in a transfer of business?
The files of the transferring employees generally go to the purchaser. Data of other employees remains with the administration. A complete state should be preserved before the handover.
This article is for general information purposes and does not replace legal advice in the individual case.
Direct line
Urgent preservation?
Call us. We usually agree the scope and next steps during the first conversation.
- Response usually on the same working day
- Preservation on site or remotely
- Binding quotation in advance
Read more
More guides
Liquidating a GmbH: checklist for IT and data from the dissolution resolution to custody of the records
What managing directors and liquidators should do with accounts, cloud, accounting, servers, website, hardware and paper records in each phase of the liquidation, so that nothing is missing once the GmbH has been deleted.
Read article →Selling customer data in insolvency: value, permissibility, process
How insolvency administrators realise a customer database in an asset deal, which data may be transferred without consent and how the value of a customer base can be estimated reliably.
Read article →Continuation of business operations: keeping IT running in insolvency
How insolvency administrators keep IT stable during the continuation of business operations: critical systems, service providers and estate liabilities, key personnel, data preservation and an emergency plan.
Read article →