Guides

Insolvency avoidance review: the data you really need

Which data sources are relevant to the individual grounds for avoidance under §§ 129 et seq. InsO, and why financial accounting alone is rarely sufficient for a robust review.

The bank statements show that a supplier regularly received payments in the months before the filing. Whether these payments can be avoided, however, is not decided by the bank statement. What matters is what the supplier knew: whether it sent reminders, agreed instalment payments or threatened to stop deliveries. This information is found in emails, in the dunning system and in notes of conversations. If these sources have not been preserved, the avoidance review remains incomplete. This guide shows which data is typically required for the insolvency avoidance (contestation) review, which grounds for avoidance it relates to and which periods you should preserve.

Why avoidance is a question of data

Insolvency avoidance under §§ 129 et seq. InsO (German Insolvency Code) makes it possible to reverse transfers of assets made before the insolvency filing. The administrator generally bears the burden of presentation and proof for the requirements of an avoidance claim. Statutory presumptions and eased standards of proof only help if the facts on which they are based can be evidenced.

This makes the avoidance review a question of the available data. It is not enough to know that a payment was made. What matters is when, under what circumstances and with what level of knowledge on the part of the recipient. These circumstances can only be pieced together from several data sources.

The grounds for avoidance and their periods at a glance

The grounds for avoidance differ in their requirements and periods. The following overview is intended for orientation, not as a conclusive review:

  • § 130 InsO, congruent cover: legal acts in the last three months before the request to open proceedings, or afterwards, if the debtor was illiquid and the creditor knew this or knew of the request.
  • § 131 InsO, incongruent cover: the creditor receives satisfaction or security to which it was not entitled, not entitled in that form or not entitled at that time. Depending on the case group, the relevant period is the last month or the second and third months before the request.
  • § 133 InsO, intentional disadvantage: legal acts with the intention of disadvantaging creditors, if the other party knew of this intention. In principle, the last ten years before the request are covered, reduced to four years for acts of cover.
  • § 134 InsO, gratuitous performance: gratuitous performance by the debtor in the last four years before the request.
  • § 135 InsO, shareholder loans: security for shareholder loans in the last ten years and repayments in the last year before the request.

The details, in particular the exceptions, presumptions and interpretation by the courts, must be examined in each individual case.

Some periods go back as far as ten years. That is considerably longer than many companies actively keep emails or dunning histories. You should therefore preserve complete data sets, not just the current years.

Which data source for which ground

Bank statements and payment transactions

Bank statements and payment transaction data show which payments went to whom and when. They are the starting point of every review. In addition to the banks' statements, data from the payment software is useful, such as payment orders with reference text and approval history. Direct debits, set-offs and payments via third parties should also be identifiable.

Open item lists and accounts receivable or payable ledgers

Open item lists show how long liabilities remained outstanding. Payment arrears over a longer period can be an indication of illiquidity or suspension of payments. Historical states are important, not just the position on the filing date. The accounts payable ledgers show whether payments were made on older invoices while newer ones remained unpaid.

Dunning and instalment agreements

Reminders, payment reminders, requests for deferral and instalment agreements are particularly telling as to the creditor's knowledge of illiquidity. Whether a request for instalment payments allows an inference of knowledge in an individual case depends on the circumstances. Without the records, however, the question cannot even be asked.

Email correspondence with creditors

Emails often contain the decisive clues: threats to stop deliveries, requests for payment deferral, arrangements for partial payments. They are equally relevant for §§ 130, 131 and 133 InsO. How mailboxes are preserved completely and in searchable form is covered in the guide on email mailboxes in insolvency.

Enforcement records

Attachments, enforcement orders and payments made under the pressure of enforcement can be significant for incongruence under § 131 InsO. These records exist partly on paper, partly as scans on the file server or as vouchers in the accounting system.

Shareholder accounts and contracts

For § 135 InsO, loan agreements, shareholders' clearing accounts and repayments are needed. For § 134 InsO, contracts that show whether or not there was consideration are important: gifts, guarantees for third parties, payments to related parties. Contracts are frequently scattered across file servers, document management systems and email attachments.

Metadata and timestamps

For dating events, exact dates are often crucial: when did a reminder arrive, when was a payment approved, when was an agreement amended? Metadata such as the send and receive times of emails or modification dates of documents provide this information. It is only retained, however, if preservation is faithful to the original. If files are merely copied or emails printed to PDF, metadata is partly lost or altered.

Records outside the company

Not all relevant information is held in the debtor's systems. Banks can provide statements and transaction lists for past periods on request, bailiffs and enforcement courts hold enforcement files, and tax advisers often retain older accounting data. Such sources supplement the company's own data but do not replace it, because internal correspondence and notes are missing there.

Why financial accounting alone is not enough

Financial accounting shows that a booking was made, but hardly why. It shows payment flows and balances, but as a rule contains no correspondence, no notes of conversations and only rarely the complete dunning records. The subjective elements in particular, i.e. knowledge and intent, can rarely be proven from bookings alone.

In addition, accounting data may be condensed: collective postings, subsequent corrections or incompletely recorded vouchers. Reconciliation with the original sources, i.e. bank statements, vouchers and correspondence, is therefore usually unavoidable. Guidance on preserving the accounting system itself is contained in the guide on DATEV data in insolvency.

Which periods you should preserve

The avoidance periods result in a minimum scope based on the longest applicable period. In practice, a generous approach is advisable:

  1. Payment transactions and accounting: as complete as possible for the entire available period, but at least for the periods under §§ 133 and 135 InsO.
  2. Email mailboxes: complete mailboxes including archives, deleted items and local archive files, not just the current inbox.
  3. Dunning and open item history: historical states from the merchandise management or financial accounting system, not just current lists.
  4. File stores: complete file servers and cloud storage, as contracts and agreements are rarely kept in one place.

Narrowing the scope later is always possible; extending it later often is not. If you initially preserve only selected periods, you risk older data having been deleted or overwritten by the time you need it.

Preserve completely first, then analyse in a targeted way. Narrowing down to relevant periods and creditors happens during the analysis, not during preservation.

From preservation to analysis

Large data sets can only be analysed with structure. A proven approach is to index the preserved sources and search them specifically by creditor, period and key terms. Hits are linked to payment data, producing a traceable chronology for individual creditors. How such research can be structured is described on the page Data preparation and research.

For later proceedings, the integrity of the data is also important. Checksums and a preservation log prove that the data presented corresponds to the preserved data set. The significance of this for the taking of evidence is covered in the guide on data preservation, archiving and evidence preservation.

Beweisanker takes care of the complete insolvency data preservation of all relevant sources and prepares the data so that you can carry out the avoidance review in a targeted way.

Frequently asked questions

Are bank statements sufficient for the avoidance review?

Bank statements prove the flow of payments. For the subjective requirements, such as the creditor's knowledge of illiquidity, further sources such as correspondence and dunning records are generally needed.

How far back should emails be preserved?

As avoidance for intentional disadvantage under § 133 InsO in principle covers up to ten years, a complete preservation of all available mailboxes and archives without any time limit is advisable.

Which data is important for the avoidance of shareholder loans?

In particular loan agreements, shareholders' clearing accounts, repayments and interest payments, as well as security granted. The periods under § 135 InsO must be examined in the individual case.

Can I limit the avoidance review to financial accounting?

That is possible, but it carries the risk that facts indicating knowledge or intent will not be identified. Supplementing it with correspondence and contract documents is generally advisable.

This guide is for general information only and does not replace legal advice in an individual case.

Direct line

Urgent preservation?

Call us. We usually agree the scope and next steps during the first conversation.

  • Response usually on the same working day
  • Preservation on site or remotely
  • Binding quotation in advance

Read more

More guides

Liquidating a GmbH: checklist for IT and data from the dissolution resolution to custody of the records

What managing directors and liquidators should do with accounts, cloud, accounting, servers, website, hardware and paper records in each phase of the liquidation, so that nothing is missing once the GmbH has been deleted.

Read article →

Selling customer data in insolvency: value, permissibility, process

How insolvency administrators realise a customer database in an asset deal, which data may be transferred without consent and how the value of a customer base can be estimated reliably.

Read article →

Continuation of business operations: keeping IT running in insolvency

How insolvency administrators keep IT stable during the continuation of business operations: critical systems, service providers and estate liabilities, key personnel, data preservation and an emergency plan.

Read article →

Every day counts.

Talk to us as soon as proceedings are on the horizon. Together we establish which systems are affected and what needs to be preserved first.

Operating nationwide (Germany) · on site at short notice in Baden-Württemberg and German-speaking Switzerland